Butt Paste vs Desitin

No matter how hard you try, at some point, babies are bound to get diaper rash. In certain cases, a diaper rash can end up being very severe that you’d have thought. There are certain creams such as the Butt Paste vs Desitin, have been created to help with diaper rash. While it’s not always a guarantee that your little one won’t get it, there are various tips on how to prevent diaper rash with the most obvious one being to ensure your baby doesn’t stay too long with a wet diaper. So, what makes the Butt Paste and Desitin different?

Butt Paste vs Desitin Specifications

Both the Butt Paste and the Desitin have Zinc Oxide as an active ingredient. However, the percentage of the Zinc Oxide available in Butt Pate is higher than that available on the Desitin by 3 percent. While the Butt Pate is made of 16 percent Zinc Oxide, the Desitin is made up of 13 percent. The Butt Pate also has other ingredients such as the castor oil seed, paraffin, mineral oil, resin, balsam tolu, and petrolatum. Desitin, on the other hand also has other ingredients such as the mineral oil, petrolatum, beeswax, glycerin, etc.

The Butt Paste cream comes in 16, four- and two-ounce containers while the Desitin cream comes in a tube, tub form, and in 16, six, four- and two-ounce containers. In addition, the Butt Paste is very thick compared to the Desitin cream that is very lightweight hence easily applicable with every diaper change. The Butt Paste doesn’t have a strong smell, which is very common with most diaper rash creams. This means you don’t have to worry about your baby breathing in its smell. Desitin, on the other hand, has a bit of a strong smell which though not completely uncomfortable, may be unsettling for some.

Because of how thick the Butt Paste is, wiping it off completely from your baby’s butt can be a bit hard. However, Desitin, on the other hand, is a lot easier to wipe off, given that as we mentioned earlier, is lightweight cream. In terms of pricing, depending on the size you choose, the prices for both creams vary even though Desitin is slightly costlier than Butt Paste.

Butt Paste vs Desitin Basics

As we started by mentioning above, both creams have Zinc Oxide as an active ingredient. Of course, there are also other inactive ingredients that both creams have, such as petrolatum, mineral oil, etc. Both creams can be used to not only treat, but to also prevent diaper rush. When it comes to prevention, what you can do is start applying either of the creams you choose to buy the minute you realize any signs that your baby might be getting diaper rash.

Because of the Zinc Oxide active ingredient, both creams do an excellent job of soothing your little one’s rash as well as sealing out any wetness before you can put on a fresh diaper on your baby. Both creams can also be used for more than just diaper rash. They can be used on dry skin on both babies, children, and adults alike. In fact, adults can also use either of the cream to treat rashes in unsightly places.

In terms of cleaning, both creams can be applied the same way. All that is required is to clean and dry the affected area and then apply the cream before putting on a new diaper. In addition, you can use them when changing diapers during the day, as well as at bedtime and naptime. Both Butt Paste and Desitin have very good reviews from customers and almost never miss in most reviews for diaper rash creams.

Butt Paste vs Desitin Quality

Choosing the type of cream to purchase can be a bit tricky. Why? Because there may be other inactive ingredients that can worsen the diaper rash and if unknown to you, can only do more harm than good. As a first rule of thumb, it’s always important to consult your baby’s pediatrician regardless of how mild or moderate you think the rash is.

While these two creams work almost the same way, the Butt Paste is a darling of many because of the high Zinc Oxide available as it allows it to work fast, providing your baby with the much-needed relief. And while the 3 percent more Zinc Oxide is a plus for the Butt Paste, it may not be a darling to everyone as it’s a bit thick compared to Desitin. They also come in different versions, and both are an excellent choice for mild to severe diaper rash.

Butt Paste vs Desitin Pros and Cons

Butt Paste


  • This cream can be used as a preventative measure even in instances where your baby doesn’t have any diaper rash
  • Butt Paste doesn’t have any strong smell
  • Works very fast to clear up diaper rash and can be used by both children and adults alike


  • The cream is too thick which becomes a bit hard to wipe away the cream left after use
  • Because of how thick it is, it can be hard to easily spread it on your baby’s bottom



  • It works quickly when applied to your baby’s bottom to provide the needed relief
  • You can easily wipe it away from your baby’s skin, so it’s easy to apply another fresh coat with each diaper change
  • Thick enough to remain on your baby’s skin and take effect without necessarily running off on your baby’s diaper


  • It has a very strong smell
  • It’s not as thick as Butt Paste hence it doesn’t entirely stick for long

Final Thoughts

It’s important that you always consider all the ingredients used in whatever cream you go for. This is because babies tend to have very sensitive skin, and they can react poorly to certain ingredients, which in turn can lead to a flare up of the diaper rash. To ensure this doesn’t happen, always consult your baby’s doctor before you start any home treatments. That said, between the two, we’d most definitely recommend the Butt Paste as it has no strong smell, is thick, which means it’ll last longer on your baby’s bottom and works very fast to provide the healing and relief your little one needs.