Best Pacifiers for Breastfed Babies

Breastfed babies can be very picky. Whether it’s the feeding bottles they feed from or the pacifiers they use. As such, when picking the best pacifiers for breastfed babies, it’s not enough to just get one because every other mum is getting one. You need to get a pacifier that is comfortable and one that they can easily get used to.

In addition, you need to consider the construction, quality, and durability before deciding to buy a pacifier. Still, while all those are important features to look out for, it all boils down to whether your baby will actually like the pacifier. To assist you in choosing the best pacifier for your baby, we’ve reviewed some of the best pacifiers that you can get in the market today.

Pacifiers for Breastfed Babies Reviews

MAM Glow in the Dark Pacifiers

MAM Glow In the Dark Pacifiers, Baby Pacifier 0-6 Months, Best Pacifier for Breastfed Babies, "Night

MAM pacifiers are very popular. This is because they are efficient and do what they need to do. Their sucking mechanism doesn’t cause any harm, and they are excellent when it comes to soothing your baby. Its most prominent feature is its ability to glow in the dark, which is something most pacifiers don’t have.


  • Excellent choice for parents who want a pacifier that’s harmless and one that soothes their baby
  • Has a unique design that lets it glow in the dark hence you won’t need to switch on the lights to find it
  • Made from pliable silicone
  • This pacifier has an upright feature that ensures it’s always put in your baby’s mouth the right way
  • MAM offers this pacifier in three different sizes allowing your kid to grow into the different sizes available past 16 months of age
  • Easy to clean as it only takes three minutes to clean using a microwave
  • Comes with a case that can be used to store them in the diaper bag when moving from one point to the next
  • It has some large air holes that help prevent skin irritation


  • Some customers have reported that the glow is a bit weak
  • This pacifier doesn’t have a ring to hold
Check Price on Amazon

Philips Avent BPA Free Pacifier

Philips Avent BPA Free Soothie Pacifier, 3+ months, Green, 2 pack, SCF192/05

Philips is very famous when it comes to manufacturing quality baby products. This pacifier also gets distributed in hospitals nationwide to help mums get a rest from nursing. It has a simple design that makes it an excellent choice for breastfed babies.


  • This Philips pacifier is always distributed in different hospitals nationwide to help mums get a break from nursing
  • Used by medical professionals to help soothe and relax babies
  • Easy for your baby to use as it easily goes into the mouth straight up and then curves
  • Shaped like a nipple hence your little one won’t struggle sucking
  • Easy to clean as you can wash it in the dishwasher or use a sanitizer to clean it
  • Made from silicone and is BPA free which makes it safe for your baby
  • It has a one-piece construction that is thick with holes incorporated in the design to help with ventilation
  • It’s available in three different colors – blue, pink and green – to suit your preference and is also quite affordable compared to other pacifiers in our review


  • Some babies – especially newborns – find the nipple a bit too large to fit into their mouth properly
  • The round shield is quite large and can easily push into the noses of some babies
Check Price on Amazon

Ecopacifier Natural Pacifier

Ecopacifier Natural Pacifier Rounded (3 pack) 0-6 Months

Now, if you are looking for a pacifier that is all-natural and is a lot more friendly to your breastfed baby, then you need to consider the Ecopacifier Natural Pacifier. It’s an excellent choice for newborns as it’s available in two sizes – 0-6 months and 6 months plus.


  • You can purchase it in the rounded or orthodontic shape even though the rounded shape is an excellent choice for breastfed babies
  • It’s available in two different sizes – 0-6 months and 6 months plus – giving you the freedom to choose it in a size that works for your little one
  • It’s an all-natural pacifier
  • It’s a one-piece pacifier with a pure rubber construction gotten from the Hevea Brasillensi rubber tree
  • The rubber build means that this pacifier is free from ant colorants or chemicals
  • It’s free of BPA, PVC, plastic, parabens, and phthalate
  • Against your baby’s gums, the rubber feels really good making it great if your baby is teething
  • Being a one-piece pacifier, it’s easy to clean because it holds less grime and dirt and doesn’t hold any water after cleaning
  • You can relax knowing that the pacifier won’t leave any marks on your baby’s face compared to other pacifiers


  • It’s slightly expensive
  • It’s only available in two sizes which means you will need to look for a new option once your baby outgrows the two sizes
Check Price on Amazon

Evenflo Feeding Pacifier

Evenflo Feeding Balance Plus Stage 1 Cylindrical Baby, Newborn and Infant Pacifier - Developed with Pediatric Feeding Specialists - 0 to 6 Months (Pack of 2)

This pacifier from Evenflo has a very simple design built for a purpose. It has a rounded stage that mimics the breast and boosts a natural tongue position. It’s a one-piece soother that has a handle that’s easy to grip.


  • This pacifier has a simple design built for a purpose
  • Its rounded design helps to mimic the breast and also helps promote an all-natural tongue position
  • It’s a one-piece pacifier that is very flexible and has a grip handle that’s easy to use for both mum and baby
  • The flexibility provided by this pacifier helps reduce mouth fatigue for your baby
  • It has a silicone construction and is BPA, PVC, phthalates, and polycarbonates free
  • Very easy to clean thanks to the simple design
  • It comes with a team sanitizing bag that is re-sealable and can be popped into the microwave for a quick cleaning
  • Has an antifatigue feature that aids in preventing SIDS while the shield holes prevent the pooling of drool


  • It’s only available in one color, white, which can also discolor very fast
  • Some customers complained that the silicone material used it too soft
  • It’s only sold in one size – 0-6 months – meaning you will be back in the market for a new pacifier once your baby is older than six months
Check Price on Amazon

Final Thoughts

Pacifier are not a must have. You can opt to purchase one for your baby or not. However, if you need to get a break from nursing your baby and still keeping them relaxed and soother, a pacifier is an excellent item to purchase. In addition, they also help reduce the risk of SIDS because your baby will sleep less soundly as they continue sucking which in turn helps reduce their risk of falling into a deep sleep.

While pacifiers are great to have, it’s important that parents don’t use them to shut them up when crying or when feeding your baby. Used the right way, a pacifier can be very beneficial to both mother and child.